Thursday, October 21, 2010

If You Oppose Streetcars, You Just Don't Know Much

Don’t expect streetcars to come to Bountiful soon
byMelinda Williams
Oct 18, 2010 | 491 views | 0 0 comments |  | 4 4 recommendations | email to a friend | print
BOUNTIFUL — Salt Lake City officials are hopeful the federal government will soon pick up the tab on at least some of their streetcar projects, but Bountiful City officials don’t believe South Davis will see streetcars anytime soon.

Bountiful City planner Aric Jensen said he believes some of the Salt Lake City lines are shovel ready, that is, builders can proceed as soon as funding is available.

That’s not the case in Bountiful or Centerville, where there’s been no engineering or other preparatory work done — and that may be several years out.

“Much (of South Davis’ streetcar plans) will depend on if Salt Lake City has success with their lines,” Jensen said. “It will take a more progressive city like Salt Lake to initially install it and make it a success.”

He said that if Salt Lake commuters readily take to the streetcars, it will pave the way for streetcars to be considered, not only in south Davis County, but in areas of Salt Lake County, like Rose Park — areas Jensen described as being on the fringe of Salt Lake City.

One of the problems he sees with proceeding with a streetcar plan for Bountiful and Centerville is that people don’t seem to know a lot about how they operate.

Jensen describes South Davis residents as being wary and cautious about streetcars, much the same as Wasatch Front residents were about light rail before the TRAX lines were installed. Now, TRAX is pretty much viewed as just another way to get around Salt Lake City and many Davis County residents use TRAX when in Salt Lake City. He believes the same thing will happen with streetcars.

Jensen said commuter rail provides a means for commuters to get to a destination 15, 20 or 25 miles away, and light rail can provide transportation for those 10-15 miles away. Streetcars are for those who need to travel only a mile to five miles. “It’s a much more personal type of transit.”

Residents’ wariness was pretty evident at two public hearings hosted by the Utah Transit Authority last spring in Centerville and Bountiful,where hundreds of residents turned out to protest the plan and the proposed route.

As to future streetcar funding in Davis County, “a lot depends on what happens in the (November) elections. Much depends on the political structure.”


Read more:Davis County Clipper - News, Classifieds, Events and Businesses in Davis County, Utah

ksl.com - Sugar House streetcar project awarded $26 million

ksl.com - Sugar House streetcar project awarded $26 million

Salt Lake City Streetcars?

Salt Lake City leaders seeking federal funds for downtown streetcar system

Group says government recently has shown support for similar projects across the country

Published: Thursday, Oct. 14, 2010 1:05 a.m. MDT
E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
SALT LAKE CITY — Utah's capital city will need help from the federal government to get streetcars rolling downtown, according to consultants tasked with determining feasibility of the project.
HDR Engineering Inc. and Pehr & Peers on Tuesday presented to city leaders the results of a yearlong study about how and where a streetcar system would work in the downtown area.
Using criteria such as area demographics, zoning and activity generators, the consultants identified an initial alignment for a trolley-style rail line designed to shuttle pedestrians around downtown as well as bolster business and development.
The consultants recommend building the project in two phases, with the first of those connecting the future Harmons grocery store at City Creek Center on the corner of 100 South and 200 East with Salt Lake Central Station at approximately 600 West and 300 South.
The 1.7-mile line is proposed to be built on the outside lane of both sides of the street and cost between $49.2 million and $55.5 million.
The consultants estimate that connecting the streetcar with Salt Lake Central Station, making it easily accessible from TRAX and FrontRunner, would increase expected ridership by 30 percent.
The second phase of the route would extend the streetcar line south along 400 West and then east to the TRAX station at 900 South. That 1.2-mile extension has an estimated price tag of between $20.5 million and $25.3 million.
Federal funds will be required for the project to be a success, the consultants said.
The good news for Salt Lake City, the consultants said, is that the federal government recently has shown support for streetcar projects across the nation.
Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood and Federal Transit Administrator Peter Rogoff "have been effusive in their praise for streetcar projects," the consultants wrote in the 72-page study.
In addition, the U.S. Department of Transportation and Federal Transit Administration have put more than $300 million into capital grants for streetcar projects in the past 12 months, according to the report.
"This changed environment makes the federal government a credible potential funding partner for the a Salt Lake City project," the report states.
Salt Lake City's Redevelopment Agency already has submitted a grant application to the FTA to conduct further analysis on the proposed downtown streetcar alignments.
In the meantime, the consultants suggested that Salt Lake City officials coordinate planning efforts and capital projects with the project in mind. They also recommended that city officials have further discussions with the Utah Transit Authority about options for operating the streetcars.Salt Lake City Councilman Carlton Christensen said the process for bringing a streetcar system to downtown is about two years behind plans in Sugar House.
That proposed line would run from the 2100 South TRAX station to the old Granite Furniture building in Sugar House.
In February, city leaders learned that the Sugar House streetcar line was not selected by federal transportation officials to receive a piece of $1.5 billion in stimulus money.
The RDA is waiting to hear on its most recent grant application for federal funding.
"We're really focused on getting the Sugar House streetcar line done," said Luke Garrott, city councilman and chairman of the RDA board.
Garrott noted that completing the Sugar House streetcar line likely would build momentum for a downtown system.
"Sugar House is definitely the first piece that needs to happen," he said, "and we'll know a lot more after the Sugar House line gets built."

Sugarhouse Streetcar Coming Soon

Salt Lake City receives $26 million for Sugar House streetcar project

Published: Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2010 4:08 p.m. MDT
E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
SALT LAKE CITY — In October 2007, Ralph Becker stood on the corner of McClelland Street and Sugarmont Drive and announced his intentions to make a light-rail or trolley route to Sugar House a high priority under his administration.
Becker, then a candidate for mayor, insisted that by working together with the Utah Transit Authority and South Salt Lake, the line could move forward much sooner than what then was a 20- to 25-year timetable.
A few days shy of three years later, Mayor Becker returned to that same corner Wednesday to celebrate a $26 million federal grant that will allow the Sugar House streetcar project to move forward immediately and possibly be operational within three years.
"I am pleased to announce that by securing the TIGER II grant, we have identified a crucial piece of federal funding to take the Sugar House streetcar from vision to reality," he said.
The Sugar House streetcar line was one of 42 capital construction projects awarded federal funding Wednesday through the Transportation Investment Generating Economic Recovery program. The second round of the federal stimulus funding, known as TIGER II grants, will put nearly $600 million toward major infrastructure projects in 40 states, ranging from highways and bridges to transit, rail and ports.
City leaders say the $26 million awarded to the Sugar House project will jump-start construction of the two-mile streetcar line from the 2100 South TRAX station to the old Granite Furniture building.
Only three projects received more TIGER II funding than the Sugar House streetcar line. The largest grant, nearly $47.7 million, went to a streetcar project in Atlanta.
"These are innovative, 21st century projects that will change the U.S. transportation landscape by strengthening the economy and creating jobs, reducing gridlock and providing safe, affordable and environmentally sustainable transportation choices," U.S. Department of Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood said in a news release. "Many of these projects could not have been funded without this program.
Ralph Jackson, UTA's deputy chief of major program development, said project officials had applied for a $31 million grant, though he noted that the $26 million will be sufficient for the project to get under way immediately.
The full cost of the streetcar project has been estimated at $46 million, a figure that doesn't include the right of way for the line acquired years ago by UTA. But Salt Lake City transportation officials have been working with UTA to find ways to trim that price tag, Becker saidOne example of that is the possibility that cars already being acquired for UTA's TRAX system could be converted for streetcar use. That would also eliminate the need for separate maintenance facilities and operations, he said. "That saves an enormous amount of money in terms of development of the system," Becker said. Salt Lake City Councilman S?ren Simonsen described plans for a streetcar in Sugar House as "going back to the future," noting that the community was built on trolley lines that operated in the early part of the 20th century.
"We're bringing back technologies," Simonsen said, "but this will be a very modern trolley system. It will have a lot of things that historic trolleys didn't have in terms of accessibility for people with disabilities and our ability to integrate and tie in with other modes of transportation, pedestrians and bicyclists."
The project also will be unique in that the streetcar won't actually run on a street, he noted. Project plans call for the streetcar or trolley to use the abandoned railroad corridor between 2100 South and I-80.
The streetcar line also will be integrated with the Parleys Trail, creating what Simonsen says has the "opportunity to become a tremendous corridor that's really focused on transit and pedestrians."
The slower-moving streetcar would stop more frequently than a TRAX train, picking up and dropping off riders every other block. Streetcars in U.S. cities, including Portland, Ore., have shown to increase foot traffic to shops and restaurants along the line, city officials said. The permanency of the tracks spurs development in areas because the system guarantees people will have easy access specific locations.
It's a twist on the popular model of transit-oriented development, Becker said, in that the transit element is the catalyst for surrounding development.
City leaders have visited Portland and other U.S. cities with streetcar systems and have seen firsthand what they can do for an area.
"If it follows the examples of what we've seen in other areas in the country that have had (streetcars), you're going to see housing and apartments. You're going to see businesses," said JT Martin, City Council chairman. "You're going to see Sugar House come back like it was in its glory day."
In addition to encouraging development in the area, Jackson said the streetcar line will make it possible for people in Sugar House to connect with the rest of UTA's 150-mile rail system — and vice versa.
"(People will be able to) go anywhere in the valley right from this location," he said.
The Department of Transportation received nearly 1,000 construction grant applications for more than $19 billion from all 50 states, U.S. territories and Washington, D.C.
The high volume of requests for TIGER II project dollars follows a similar demand for the $1.5 billion awarded in February 2009 through the TIGER I program. The Sugar House project also was a candidate for those funds but was not selected.
Jackson said UTA and city officials were "quite optimistic" the Sugar House streetcar project would be among those receiving funding in the second round of grants.
"When we talked to the federal people when the last set of grants were issued, they told us we were right at the top of the list; we were just below the cutoff," he said. "So we were feeling quite positive in this next go-round that this project would be included and receive a grant."